Nov 2020

Applications of HeLD to Cartridge Package Development and Validation

Applications of HeLD to Cartridge Package Development and Validation

In a recent blog, we discussed the application of helium leak detection (HeLD) as part of a capping optimization study or assembly validation for glass and plastic vials. A defining characteristic of helium leak detection, instruments such as the SIMS 1284+ have sensitivity capable of measurement below the maximum allowable leakage limit (MALL) of many pharmaceutical and medical device products. This allows for study-based comparisons and data-informed decision making at a very fine scale. More importantly, these types of studies can be used to support regulatory documentation and in fulfillment of guidance such as USP <1207>.

While applications of this approach to vials are well established, if increasingly popular, very similar approaches can be taken for other common package systems used in the industry. Cartridges, which are frequently used as part of a device delivery system, are one such format. Similar to a traditional vial, one end of a cartridge is typically sealed with an elastomer-lined crimp. Compared to that of a 20mm or 13mm vial, cartridge crimp seals are relatively small and intricate. On the other end, a cartridge is typically sealed by an elastomeric plunger, similar to that which may be found on a syringe. Each of these unique sealing interfaces present specific challenges from a CCI perspective.

Considering the crimp interface of the cartridge, similar studies as for a vial can be performed to optimize and validate component choice as well as assembly parameters and processes. Comparative studies can be performed to choose the most robust cartridge-seal combination given machinability limits. Studies involving multiple crimp configurations, in conjunction with HeLD and RSF, can help elucidate a set of capping parameters that consistently yields an integral seal with low leakage. As with vials, it is possible that dimensional stack-ups, in conjunction with limitations in machinability, yield defects such as loose crimps, misaligned seals, stress cracking from high crimp force, etc. Characterizing these risks through quantitative, deterministic analyses can inform mitigation strategies and quality decision making about the assembly process. With final components and assembly parameters chosen, assembly validation using cartridges capped real-time can be performed, fulfilling best practices outlined through industry standard guidance such as USP <1207>.

Unlike the crimp-sealed end, the barrel end of a cartridge is less a function of an applied force. However, similar optimization and assembly validation practices apply. As with any package system requiring a high degree of leak protection, early on in the development process, the inherent integrity of the chosen product-package system should be evaluated, essentially answering the question: “Are these components, when mated optimally, capable of creating an integral seal?”. This extends to the choice of suitable barrel-plunger interfaces as well. Arguably, since the barrel-plunger interface is not a function of a controllable process such as crimping, inherent integrity evaluations become even more critical. The achieved seal will be primarily a function of the dimensional overlap between the cartridge inner diameter and the plunger outer diameter.

In a laboratory setting, consider a study designed to evaluate barrel-plunger samples paired at dimensional extremes. Within their respective dimensional tolerances, the widest barrel inner diameter paired with the smallest plunger presents the highest risk for leakage, as there may be insufficient or inconsistent compression of the plunger against the cartridge wall. On the other hand, consider the smallest barrel inner diameter paired with the widest plunger. In this case, it is critical to ensure proper function, lack of stress-related defects such as cracking or fitment-related issues risking leakage, such as mis-aligned plungers. A study exploring these dimensional extremes provides confidence that components, within their dimensional stack-up ranges, will provide integral seals. This can be further confirmed by assessing real-world cartridges assembled on the line.

This type of work can be performed at a production facility, using client-owned instrumentation or in-house contract services. Additionally, LDA’s sample filler allows for sample preparation at time of test, enabling analysis of samples previously produced and sealed, or transfer of samples between manufacturing and testing sites. With increasing regulatory scrutiny as well as risk in poor package development and validation practices, helium leak detection, as enabled by the LDA SIMS 1284+ system, is a versatile tool in generating a robust foundation of CCI data for modern package systems

SIMS 1284+, helium leak detection, application of helium leak detection
Jun 2020

Leak Detection Associates Names Key Executives to Leadership Roles

Leak Detection Associates Names Key Executives to Leadership Roles


Leak Detection Associates (LDA), the world’s leading provider of helium based leak testing systems for the pharmaceutical, biotechnology and food industries, formally announced today the appointment of two key leadership executives to guide the company moving forward. Brian Mulhall has been named Chief Executive Officer and will oversee all aspects of the company’s operations, including product development, manufacturing, client services, sales and marketing. He will also be charged with leading the company’s global expansion plans going forward. Alan Weiss has been named Chief Financial Officer and will take charge of all financial aspects of the company’s operations. Mr. Mulhall and Mr. Weiss form an experienced team, working together with proven success for well over twenty years. Most recently, the pair served in the same roles for Whitehouse Analytical Laboratories, a company they founded in 2002 and ultimately sold to AMRI in December of 2015.

Commented Mr. Mulhall, “I am excited about this opportunity, as I know Dr. Morrow and his team have been on the leading edge of helium leak testing systems for over 20 years. The foundation is in place for us to assemble a team of leaders dedicated to vastly improving and expanding the LDA program, and I look forward to taking part in our future plans for success.”

“I share Brian’s excitement and enthusiasm, and we are looking forward to a bright future for LDA. They possess a truly unique approach and solution to leak testing systems, especially as it relates to key industries like pharma and biotech. The experience and commitment the current LDA team brings gives us a strong platform on which to build,” added Alan Weiss.

A number of formal plans and announcements will be forthcoming in the next few months. Concurrently, LDA’s lead product, a helium leak test system called the SIMS 1284+ combines the latest in helium leak detection technology with its proprietary SIMS software for data collection and analysis of various package systems. When using helium as a tracer gas, package leakage can be quantitatively measured to levels far exceeding the sensitivity of traditional bubble and dye penetration tests, as well as modern technologies with other unique applications, such as pressure decay, mass extraction, and high voltage leak detection. The LDA system is a plug-and-play solution for analysis by ASTM F2391-05, a method authored by LDA’s founder, Dr. Darrell Morrow, and is fundamentally represented in guidance documents such as the USP 1207 general chapter.

Using uniquely designed test fixtures, quantitative leak rate data as garnered by the LDA SIMS1284+ has supported a full range of package systems, including cold form aluminum blisters, foil pouches, vials, syringes, and cartridges requiring a higher level of seal and closure integrity to provide gas permeation or microbial ingress protection and security. While the instrument provides options for pass/fail package seal quality and container closure integrity testing, tailored applications allow evaluation of unique and specific study goals, such as a direct comparison of various packaging materials and forms, production line settings, or stability storage conditions. Flexible in its use, the technology and equipment can be used across a product lifecycle; in package design, tooling qualification, production line setup and package quality monitoring.



SIMS 1284+, packaging seal integrity testing, ASTM F2391-05

Popular Blogs


2019 PDA Container Closure Integrity Testing Workshop Presentation

Nov 03, 2020   |   276

The 2019 PDA Container Closure Integrity Testing Workshop in Gothenburg, Sweden, had the following presentation that was given as a 20 minute introduction to the use of helium leak detection for container closure integrity testing (CCIT).

Leak Detection Associates Announces New and Updated Helium Leak Detection System

Nov 01, 2020   |   268

Leak Detection Associates (LDA), the world’s premier manufacturer of custom built, helium-based leak testing instruments is excited to announce the launch of its newest and most advanced helium leak detection system, the SIMS Model 1915 that is engineered incorporating industry-leading Agilent Technologies components and is custom designed to meet the stringent requirements of clients in FDA-regulated industries.

Leak Detection Associates Celebrates Major 2019 Milestones

Dec 27, 2019   |   250

Leak Detection Associates (LDA), the world’s premier manufacturer of custom built, helium-based leak testing instruments for the Pharmaceutical, Biotechnology, Medical Device and Food Packaging Industries is excited to celebrate the completion of its first calendar year under new management.

The Advantages of Using Helium for Leak Testing

May 13, 2020   |   207

The use of helium gas as a medium for leak testing dates back to the 1940’s.Using helium as the “tracer” gas enables the user to discover and measure extremely small leaks.

History of Helium Leak Detection

Nov 05, 2020   |   197

The genesis for the use of helium as a method for leak detection can be traced back to the 1940’s and the Manhattan Project. It was determined that helium flow as sensitive as 10-6 std?cm3 could easily be detected.